Malcolm ZoppiMon Oct 16 2023

Is it Better to be Inside or Outside IR35?

There are advantages and disadvantages to being inside or outside IR35, with different implications for those operating in the private and public sectors. It is important for contractors to understand their IR35 status to ensure compliance with the regulations and optimize their financial situation.

is it better to be inside or outside ir35

For contractors and limited company contractors, understanding the IR35 regulations is crucial for determining their employment status and tax obligations. IR35 refers to the legislation that applies to individuals who provide services to clients through an intermediary, such as a limited company or personal service company. The regulations aim to combat tax avoidance by ensuring that individuals who would be regarded as employees for tax purposes if they were engaged directly are subject to the same income tax and national insurance contributions.

As of April 2021, changes to IR35 mean that the responsibility for determining whether IR35 applies now falls on the end client in the private sector. In the public sector, this has been the case since 2017.

There are advantages and disadvantages to being inside or outside IR35, with different implications for those operating in the private and public sectors. It is important for contractors to understand their IR35 status to ensure compliance with the regulations and optimise their financial situation.

Key Takeaways

  • IR35 regulations apply to individuals who provide services to clients through an intermediary.
  • Changes to IR35 in 2021 mean that the responsibility for determining IR35 status now falls on the end client in the private sector.
  • The decision of whether to be inside or outside IR35 depends on various factors such as individual circumstances, working practices, and the specific industry.
  • It is important to seek professional advice from an accountant or tax expert to fully understand the implications and make an informed choice.
  • Contractors should carefully consider the risks and benefits associated with each status to ensure compliance with the IR35 regulations and optimise their financial situation.

Understanding IR35 and Its Implications

Private sector contractors and public sector contractors alike must understand the IR35 rules and how they affect their employment status for tax purposes. The changes to IR35 regulations that came into effect in April 2021 have had a significant impact on those operating through limited companies, and it is crucial to determine whether they are inside or outside IR35.

Employment status is a crucial factor in determining whether a contractor is regarded as an employee for tax purposes. If a contractor is deemed to be a disguised employee, they may be required to pay income tax and national insurance contributions as if they were an employee. The use of umbrella companies has become increasingly popular in recent years, but it is vital to understand the role of these companies in relation to IR35.

There is a significant difference between being inside or outside IR35. If a contractor is deemed to be working inside IR35, they will be subject to tax and national insurance contributions on their income. In contrast, if they are considered to be outside IR35, they will have greater tax benefits and can deduct business expenses from their income before paying tax and national insurance contributions.

Determining IR35 status requires a review of the contractor’s working practices and the terms of their contract. If the contract is deemed to be inside IR35, the contractor will be regarded as an employee for tax purposes and will be paid as such. In contrast, an independent IR35 contractor will be paid gross and will be responsible for managing their tax and national insurance contributions.

Comprehensive provider

Get the specialist support you need

Whether you require specialised knowledge for your business or personal affairs, Zoppi & Co can support you.

It is essential to review IR35 contracts regularly to ensure that they are compliant with the regulations. In doing so, contractors can mitigate the risks of being caught inside IR35 and facing hefty tax bills. It is also crucial to note that the determination of a contractor’s employment status is not solely based on their contract but also their working practices.

Overall, private sector contractors and public sector contractors must have a thorough understanding of the IR35 rules and how they affect their employment status. It is important to seek professional advice to determine whether a contractor is inside or outside IR35 and ensure compliance with the regulations.

Pros and Cons of Being Inside or Outside IR35

For limited companies, IR35 applies to the income tax and national insurance contributions paid on earnings. When working for an end client, you may fall inside or outside of IR35, which determines the amount of tax and national insurance you need to pay.

If you are ‘inside IR35’, you are regarded as an employee for tax purposes, and your national insurance contributions and income tax will be deducted at source by your end client or the agency through which you work. Umbrella companies can help manage this process on your behalf, but they will deduct their own fees.

If you are ‘outside of IR35’, you’re considered self-employed, and you’re responsible for managing your own tax and national insurance contributions. You may be subject to paye if you have other sources of income that result in you falling into the higher tax bracket. Additionally, you can deduct your tax and national insurance contributions from your earnings and pay the remainder as dividends.

Working outside of IR35 usually means that you are not entitled to certain employee benefits, such as holiday pay and sick pay, but you gain greater tax benefits and are responsible for managing your own tax affairs. However, operating through a limited company can increase tax efficiency and provide greater flexibility in providing services.

Determining whether IR35 applies to a contract is a complex process that involves reviewing your working practices, the terms of your contract, and the nature of your relationship with the end client. HMRC introduced changes to IR35 regulations in April 2021 that shifted the determination for the income tax and national insurance contributions payable onto the end client for private sector contractors, which has seen tens of thousands of contractors caught inside IR35.

Public sector contractors have been subject to these changes since 2017, where HMRC decides whether IR35 applies to a contract based on the working practices. If you are caught inside IR35, according to HMRC, you are considered to be operating as a ‘disguised employee’ and should pay yourself a salary to reflect this, otherwise, you may have to pay backdated income tax and national insurance contributions, which can run into the tens of thousands.

The decision of whether to be inside or outside IR35 depends on various factors such as individual circumstances, working practices, and the specific industry. It is important to seek professional advice from a commercial lawyer, accountant or tax expert to fully understand the implications and make an informed choice. Contractors and limited company contractors should carefully consider the risks and benefits associated with each status to ensure compliance with the IR35 regulations and optimise their financial situation.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Please select all the ways you would like to hear from Zoppi & Co

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

Conclusion

Contractors and limited company contractors should bear in mind the impact on tax and national insurance contributions, as well as the differences in employment status and deductions. They should also carefully review their working practices and contracts to ensure compliance with the IR35 regulations.

While operating through a limited company can offer potential tax benefits and the ability to deduct business expenses, being caught inside IR35 can result in significant financial consequences. It is therefore important to manage IR35 compliance effectively and ensure that you are paying tax and national insurance contributions correctly.

It is worth noting that changes to the IR35 regulations are set to be implemented in the private sector from April 2021. This means that contractors operating through a limited company could be regarded as an employee for tax purposes, with implications for income tax, national insurance contributions, and employee benefits such as holiday pay and sick pay.

In summary, the decision of whether to be inside or outside IR35 is not a straightforward one. Contractors and limited company contractors should carefully weigh up the risks and benefits associated with each status and seek professional advice where necessary to ensure compliance with the regulations and optimise their financial situation.

FAQ

Is it Better to be Inside or Outside IR35?

The decision of whether to be inside or outside IR35 depends on various factors such as individual circumstances, working practices, and the specific industry. It is important to seek professional advice from an accountant or tax expert to fully understand the implications and make an informed choice. Contractors and limited company contractors should carefully consider the risks and benefits associated with each status to ensure compliance with the IR35 regulations and optimise their financial situation.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of being inside or outside IR35?

The pros and cons of being inside or outside IR35 include factors such as tax and national insurance contributions, deductions, holiday pay, statutory benefits, tax efficiency, and responsibility for managing and paying taxes. Operating through a limited company may offer potential tax benefits and the ability to deduct business expenses, while being caught inside IR35 can have financial consequences and impact income tax and national insurance contributions.

How do I determine if I am inside or outside IR35?

Determining whether you are inside or outside IR35 involves considering various factors such as the nature of your working practices, the terms of your contract, and the level of control and autonomy you have over your work. It is advisable to have your IR35 contracts reviewed by an expert to ensure compliance with the regulations and avoid potential penalties from HMRC.

What is the role of HMRC in determining employment status for IR35?

HMRC plays a crucial role in determining employment status for IR35. They assess whether an individual is a genuine contractor or a disguised employee based on various criteria, including mutuality of obligation, control, and the right of substitution. HMRC’s determination carries significant weight and can have implications for tax and national insurance contributions.

What are the implications of the changes to IR35 in the private sector?

The changes to IR35 in the private sector, which came into effect in April 2021, shift the responsibility for determining employment status from the contractor to the end client. This means that many contractors previously working outside IR35 may now be deemed inside IR35, resulting in changes to their tax and national insurance contributions. It is essential for contractors to understand these changes and ensure compliance with the new rules.

How does working inside or outside IR35 affect tax and national insurance contributions?

Working inside or outside IR35 impacts tax and national insurance contributions. Contractors operating outside IR35 have more flexibility in how they manage their taxes and can potentially take advantage of tax benefits and deduct business expenses. On the other hand, being inside IR35 means that tax and national insurance contributions are deducted at source, similar to an employee, potentially resulting in higher tax liabilities.

What are the differences between being inside or outside IR35 in the private and public sectors?

The differences between being inside or outside IR35 in the private and public sectors relate to the rules and requirements set by each sector. The public sector has faced stricter regulations regarding IR35 compliance, and many contractors have been deemed inside IR35 by public sector clients. In the private sector, the recent changes to IR35 regulations have shifted the responsibility for determining employment status from the contractor to the end client.

Should I operate through a limited company or an umbrella company?

Whether you should operate through a limited company or an umbrella company depends on your individual circumstances, preferences, and the specific nature of your work. Each option has its own advantages and considerations, such as tax efficiency, administrative responsibilities, and contractual arrangements. It is advisable to seek professional advice to determine the most suitable option for your situation.

How can I ensure IR35 compliance?

Ensuring IR35 compliance involves thorough understanding of the regulations, reviewing and updating contracts, maintaining accurate records of working practices, and seeking professional advice when necessary. It is crucial to stay informed about any changes to IR35 regulations and proactively manage your tax and national insurance contributions to avoid potential penalties or disputes with HMRC.

Find out more!

If you want to read more in this subject area, you might find some of our other blogs interesting:

Disclaimer: This document has been prepared for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or financial advice. You should always seek independent professional advice and not rely on the content of this document as every individual circumstance is unique. Additionally, this document is not intended to prejudge the legal, financial or tax position of any person.

Disclaimer: This document has been prepared for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or financial advice. You should always seek independent professional advice and not rely on the content of this document as every individual circumstance is unique. Additionally, this document is not intended to prejudge the legal, financial or tax position of any person.

Comprehensive provider

Get the specialist support you need

Whether you require specialised knowledge for your business or personal affairs, Zoppi & Co can support you.