Malcolm ZoppiSat Oct 21 2023

Is the End Near for Company Purchase of Own Shares with Multiple Completion Contracts? New HMRC Guidance Explained

Transferring ownership stakes can be a layered process, especially when it involves company purchase of own shares. Navigating this with the lens of the HMRC can be intricate, making it crucial for stakeholders to understand the nuances. This article unfolds the complexities of multiple completion contracts, and how they intersect with the HMRC’s rules and […]

purchase of own shares in tranches

Transferring ownership stakes can be a layered process, especially when it involves company purchase of own shares. Navigating this with the lens of the HMRC can be intricate, making it crucial for stakeholders to understand the nuances. This article unfolds the complexities of multiple completion contracts, and how they intersect with the HMRC’s rules and regulations.

Key Takeaways:

  • Multiple Completion Mechanics: Multiple completion involves phased transactions under one contract, often used in company share buy-backs, allowing flexibility in terms of ownership transitions.
  • HMRC’s Perspective: HMRC’s interpretation of multiple completion has direct implications on capital treatment. Their viewpoint, rooted in company law, emphasizes both legal and beneficial ownership of shares.
  • Capital Treatment: HMRC’s rules determine how shares bought back by the company are treated from a capital gains tax perspective. Clearance from HMRC is essential for ensuring compliant capital treatment.
  • Connection Test: Post-sale connection with the company, especially holding more than 30% of the issued share capital, is a crucial factor influencing the tax treatment of share transactions.
  • Role of Tranches: Tranche-based completion offers an organized approach to share buy-backs. Each tranche, from the first set of shares to the last, needs distinct consideration.
  • Legal vs Beneficial Ownership: Understanding the distinction between these two forms of ownership is critical. While legal ownership refers to the official ownership recorded, beneficial ownership indicates who benefits from the shares.
  • Expert Guidance is Essential: Given the evolving nature of HMRC’s interpretations and the intricacies involved in multiple completion contracts, it’s advisable to seek expertise, such as from the Chartered Institute of Taxation.

What is Multiple Completion in Share Transactions?

A multiple completion involves executing a single contract in multiple phases or tranches. This often surfaces when a company wishes to buy back its shares but does so in phases or tranches. This method requires a robust understanding of the terms like ‘shareholder’, ‘legal ownership’, and ‘beneficial ownership’.

Why Would a Company Opt for Multiple Completion?

The reasons are multifaceted. Companies might use this strategy for financing a purchase, phased transitions, or for managing shareholder exits with minimal disruption.

How Does HMRC View Multiple Completion?

The HMRC’s interpretation is critical as it has implications on capital treatment, especially concerning clearance and connection tests. Their views often hinge on the nuances of company law and the intricacies of each multiple completion contract.

Purchase of Own Shares: The Capital Treatment

Here, the emphasis is on the HMRC’s rules regarding capital gains tax, clearance for the purchase, and how legal ownership of the shares interacts with these rules.

The Connection Test Explained

Delving deep into the stipulations of remaining connected with the company post share sale, and the importance of understanding the ownership of more than 30% of the issued share capital.

How Do Dividends and Economic Rights Fit In?

A look at the economic rights in the company and how dividends play into the realm of multiple completion and the HMRC’s viewpoint.

The Role of Tranches in Multiple Completion

Comprehensive provider

Get the specialist support you need

Whether you require specialised knowledge for your business or personal affairs, Gaffney Zoppi can support you.

From the first tranche of shares to the remaining shares, how does tranche-based completion work, and why is it significant?

Legal Vs. Beneficial Ownership: A Crucial Distinction

HMRC’s take on the difference between legal ownership and beneficial ownership is pivotal. This section elaborates on the implications of each in the lens of share buy-backs.

Common Misconceptions about Multiple Completion Contracts

Clarifying some common myths, especially the misconception surrounding single contract with multiple completion, and why it matters.

Seeking Expert Guidance: The Chartered Institute of Taxation & More

The importance of seeking expert guidance, especially in the face of ever-evolving interpretations by entities like the HMRC.

Closing Thoughts:

  • Multiple completion, though intricate, offers flexibility in managing transitions.
  • HMRC’s stance is dynamic, making regular consultations and updates essential.
  • The distinction between legal and beneficial ownership is paramount.
  • Shareholders must be well-informed to maximize benefits and remain compliant.
  • Always seek expert guidance when venturing into realms like multiple completion in share buy-backs.

Q: What does “financing a purchase” mean in the context of buying own shares in tranches?

A: “Financing a purchase” refers to the process of raising funds or obtaining financial support to cover the cost of buying own shares in tranches.

Q: What is the meaning of “ordinary share capital” in the context of purchasing own shares?

A: “Ordinary share capital” refers to the total value of all ordinary shares issued by a company, representing the ownership interests of the shareholders.

Q: When a company buys its own shares, how are the remaining shares treated?

Subscribe to our newsletter

Please select all the ways you would like to hear from Gaffney Zoppi

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.

A: When a company buys its own shares in tranches, the remaining shares can be converted into non-voting shares, even if those remaining shares originally had voting or economic rights.

Q: What is the process for granting clearance in a purchase of own shares transaction?

A: The process for granting clearance in a purchase of own shares transaction involves submitting the necessary documentation and information to the relevant authorities, such as HMRC, to obtain approval for the transaction.

Q: Who is considered a “connected person” in relation to a company?

A: A “connected person” in relation to a company refers to an individual or entity that is directly or indirectly related to the company through a close connection, such as being a shareholder, director, or employee.

Q: Can an exiting shareholder sell their shares back to the company in tranches?

A: Yes, an exiting shareholder can sell their shares back to the company in tranches, allowing for a gradual buy-back of shares over a period of time instead of all at once.

Q: How is the purchase price for the shares determined in a buy-back transaction?

A: The purchase price for the shares in a buy-back transaction is usually determined through negotiations between the company and the shareholder, taking into consideration factors such as the current market value of the shares and any agreed-upon valuation method.

Q: Can a company buy back its own shares without paying for them upfront?

A: No, a company cannot buy back its own shares without paying for them. The purchase price for the shares must be paid either in full upfront or in agreed installments as specified in the contract.

Q: What is the significance of HMRC’s confirmation regarding the capital treatment of a purchase of own shares?

A: HMRC’s confirmation regarding the capital treatment of a purchase of own shares transaction provides clarity and assurance to the company regarding the tax treatment of the transaction, ensuring compliance with relevant tax laws and regulations.

Q: Has HMRC recently changed their view on the purchase of own shares?

A: Yes, HMRC has changed their view on certain aspects of the purchase of own shares, and it is important for companies to stay informed and updated on the latest guidance and regulations provided by HMRC.

Disclaimer: This document has been prepared for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or financial advice. You should always seek independent professional advice and not rely on the content of this document as every individual circumstance is unique. Additionally, this document is not intended to prejudge the legal, financial or tax position of any person.

Comprehensive provider

Get the specialist support you need

Whether you require specialised knowledge for your business or personal affairs, Gaffney Zoppi can support you.